Fred Haise (LMP)

But, Joe, assuming the S-IVB is still stable. The object I was looking at was definitely tumbling.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay, Fred. As I recall, it was stable then, although it's tumbling now.

Fred Haise (LMP)

Okay. It probably was the SLA panel I picked up.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Right. Incidentally, I guess the guys in building 6 —

Jim Lovell (CDR)

I—I think we answer to number 9. We—at around 5:32, I think, was when we think the number 5 light came on in the S-II, and a definite vibration which was more than just a high-frequency vibration we got with the normal S-IV burn, and then the light came on. I called ECO thinking from the training that it was 7:42 and looked up at the time and realized it was early. And then, soon after the light came on, the vibration stopped and the engine or the booster smoothed down. It was very smooth from there on.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay. This may be a stupid question, but do you have any idea what the frequency of it was?

Jim Lovell (CDR)

Only to say that it was much higher—I couldn't really guess now. It was rather a rapid longitudinal vibration.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay, Jim. Stand by now for a minute, we're going to switch OMNI.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

13, Houston. I read you. We still have quite a bit of noise on the loop.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

I'll stand by. Roger.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay, Jim. It should be pretty good now. We copied you answering question number 9.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

Do you want any more comments on the S-IVB vibrations?

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

I don't think so. When you get all done, I'll—I'll make a quick check to see if the booster people have any—any additional questions. You skipped number 8, Jim; could you go back to that for a second?

Jim Lovell (CDR)

Our only comment there, Joe, was that the burn on TLI, to our knowledge, was about 3-3/4 second longer than had been predicted and that was the only thing that we really noticed; otherwise, looked like PI [?] was nominal at cut-off.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

Okay, on comparing the flight of 13 to Apollo 8, lift-off was about the same amount of vibration as I noticed on 8, but at the beginning of the flight, there was less of the sideways motion than we experienced on Apollo 8. The S-IC separation felt more violent on 13 than it did on 8, maybe that's because I was in a different seat, I don't know. But there was about three sharp transients of the cut-off and a couple of big bangs where we were thrown backwards longitudinally on our straps before the S-II went off. And the S-II was, of course, just as smooth on 13 as 8 except for the number 5 engine. And we did not experience the vibration that we experienced on 8 towards the end of the S-II burn. And the S-IVB was—had more vibration than we had on 8.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay, Jim, got all that.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

The up—the update on the ORDEAL ball was a good one. At the burn, we were about—just about 8 degrees. We had to pitch down. The yaw was right on all the way through the entire burn, and just towards the end of the burn, the ball started going black in pitch a little bit.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay, sounds good, we'll give Mike Wash a gold star on that one. Okay, Jim, stand by 1 while I see if we have any extra questions.

Expand selection up Contract selection down Close
Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Jim, while we're waiting to see if they have any more questions, I'd like to read you the booster people's preliminary analysis on the—the S-II cut-off. Over.

Expand selection down Contract selection up

Spoken on April 12, 1970, 8:39 p.m. UTC (54 years, 8 months ago). Link to this transcript range is: Tweet

Jim Lovell (CDR)

That would be very interesting. Go ahead.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay, preliminary analysis of the data indicates that the center S-II engine vibrated at a somewhat higher amplitude than we've seen on previous flights, and it started at about 160 seconds into the S-II burn. As a result of these vibrations, the engine chamber pressure decreased to the level where the two low-level thrust sensors, the thrust-okay sensors, initiated center engine cut-off. Early evaluation of data indicates that no damage occurred to the engine, and the cause of the increased vibration amplitude is still under investigation. Over.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

I thought it was the center engine.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

Joe, do you have any word on what marks we had for TLI?

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

At the time of TLI, as I recall, you had 6 seconds longer than the nominal burn which was 3 seconds longer than the B-sigma low burn, and you were also GO for a second-opportunity TLI if we had required one.

Jim Lovell (CDR)

Okay, we were just wondering because it appeared to us that we had a longer TLI burn than had been predicted.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Yes, you did. We confirmed that—that—that cut-off time just about as you saw it, and I don't have an explanation for it, but it was within the B-sigma margin.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Roger, we have no further questions. All the answers were clear and satisfactory, and we thank you very much. You can press on with the rest of your busy day.

Fred Haise (LMP)

Okay, Joe. Out window 5, I just picked up the tumbling object again so, for sure, it must have been a SLA panel. I don't think we could still be in the proximity of the S-IV at this time.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

I don't think so, Fred. It's several hundred miles aft of you. 700 miles is—is the number, I'm told. And since the SLA panel didn't make the midcourse correction, that might be it.

Fred Haise (LMP)

Yes, it's, I can't really tell for sure even through the monocular that it is, but it looks the same relative position to the stars. And the best I can tell about the same intensity and still about the same distance from us.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Can you see it tumbling. Does it have a shape, or is it a point?

Fred Haise (LMP)

No. I can tell it's tumbling; I guess the flat side not only is facing me, it's not only much brighter, it also grows larger.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Okay. Very interesting. We'll see if we can figure out where that's relative to you. They keep updating the S-IV impact on us a little bit. The last guess we had was that it will impact about the same longitude we gave you but close to zero latitude and a little bit later. You still won't be able to see it. And they're saying it might make a —

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

— they're saying it might make a 100 to 120 foot crater, too.

Fred Haise (LMP)

It'll still be past the terminator for us for awhile.

Joe Kerwin (CAPCOM)

Right. It will be at about the REV 20 terminator, so it will be late in your lunar orbit activities before you will be able to photograph it, and FAO is looking at whether we can work that in or not.